Redd & River
News

The 2021 tribal leaders' letter on the Snake River dams and treaties

In March 2021, eleven tribal leaders from the Northwest asked Congress and President Biden for a comprehensive salmon plan. Their letter tied the lower Snake River dams to treaty promises made in 1855.

By the Redd & River Editorial Team ยท Updated

On March 25, 2021, eleven tribal leaders from the Northwest released an open letter to Congress and President Joe Biden. Titled with the demand that a comprehensive plan to restore salmon cannot wait, it framed the decline of Columbia and Snake River salmon as a question of treaty obligations rather than only of fish management, and it became one of the most widely cited documents in that year's debate over the lower Snake River dams.

What the letter said

The leaders wrote that each new generation of tribal government inherits the depletion of the salmon runs, and that the crisis had reached a breaking point. They described salmon as inseparable from their peoples' food, ceremonies, culture and economies, and recalled that their ancestors had protected the right to fish in the treaties signed with the United States.

We exist because salmon exist. Open letter from eleven Northwest tribal leaders, March 25, 2021

The letter rejected what its authors described as decades of requests for more time, quoting Martin Luther King Jr.'s observation from the Letter from Birmingham Jail that the word wait has almost always meant never. It cited an Environmental Protection Agency analysis that linked the four lower Snake River dams to water temperatures harmful to fish, and called for a comprehensive regional solution that would restore the river and invest in affected communities.

Why it mattered

The letter arrived weeks after Idaho Congressman Mike Simpson published his Columbia Basin Initiative, which proposed breaching the dams. It placed tribal governments, which hold treaty rights and co-manage fisheries, at the center of the conversation, and it was echoed in resolutions by the Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians and the National Congress of American Indians calling for removal of the dams.

Opponents of breaching responded that they shared the goal of abundant salmon but disagreed on the means, pointing to the costs for power customers, farmers and ports, and to the role of ocean conditions and habitat.

What followed

In 2022 Senator Patty Murray and Governor Jay Inslee published a report on replacing the dams' services. In December 2023, four of the basin's tribes, the Nez Perce, Umatilla, Warm Springs and Yakama, signed an agreement with the federal government and the states of Oregon and Washington that paused litigation and committed funding to salmon restoration and tribal clean-energy projects. The federal government withdrew from that agreement in June 2025. The dams remain in place, and the treaty arguments made in the 2021 letter remain central to the debate.

Treaties and the courts

The legal weight of the letter rests on the treaties of 1855 and on court rulings that have interpreted them. In the 1970s, federal courts confirmed that the treaty tribes are entitled to a fair share of the harvestable fish returning to their usual and accustomed places, and later rulings held that the right implies some protection of the fish runs themselves. Tribal leaders argue that a right to fish means little without fish to catch, and that the decline of Snake River runs since the dams were completed undermines that promise.

Questions about the tribal leaders' letter

Who wrote the 2021 letter?

Eleven leaders of Northwest tribal governments signed the open letter released on March 25, 2021. It was addressed to members of Congress and to President Joe Biden.

What did the letter ask for?

A comprehensive plan to restore salmon in the Columbia basin, including restoration of the lower Snake River, combined with investments in the communities and industries that depend on the dams today.

What treaty rights are involved?

In the treaties of 1855, several Northwest tribes ceded most of their lands to the United States but reserved the right to take fish at their usual and accustomed places. Courts have since confirmed that the tribes are entitled to a share of the harvestable fish.

Did the letter lead to dam removal?

No. It added pressure during a year when breaching was widely debated, and it was followed by state and federal reports and a 2023 agreement on salmon restoration, but none of the four lower Snake River dams has been removed.